26 August, 2013

What do you do now?

The economy continues to look down cast with various indicators coming out looking decidedly bearish. The IIP numbers, Purchasing Managers Index, Inflation, GDP number etc., leave much to be desired. In the sea of misery, there is one redeeming ark – the trade deficit has narrowed sharply, which is possibly the only good news. Another one – the monsoon has been good and is expected to boost the rural incomes.

Stock markets have been buffeted by the falling rupee & the exit of money by FIIs. Equity markets have been affected & how! Among this, the mid and small cap stocks have seen massive erosions, some of them as high as 95%!!!

Consequently, mutual funds have also had their rough patch. They have fallen less due to diversification & fund manager actions, that inherently is one of the strong suits of MF schemes.

The sour point now is that even the debt markets have turned turbulent due to RBI actions, which have effectively increased the borrowing costs for the banks.  All this has put a question mark on what we need to do now. That is exactly what I’m writing for.

What do you do now ?
1.    Equity  - One of the frequently asked questions is whether the Equity SIP should be stopped.  The short answer is – No.
Equity SIPs are done with a longer investment horizon for meeting future goals. Also, the best way to invest in equity assets is through small monthly investments which does away with the need to time the markets & ensures cost averaging ( apart from various other pluses ). Hence, stopping the existing equity SIPs is not a sound idea.
As far as the existing equity investments are concerned it is better to stay put rather than change anything at this point. When the markets are in a tizzy, it pays to go by the dictum which stood our past PM ( Narasimha Rao, who was the first one to anoint it with ceremonial honours !) in good stead – No action is also action.
In due course, the markets will calm down, when the effect of the corrective action being taken, bears fruit.

2.    Debt  - After the shock treatment meted out by RBI, investors are skeptical about the debt markets too. But look at the other fact – RBI cannot keep the interest rates this high and will have to reverse it sooner than later, if it does not want to as the chief architect of a crippled economy.
Hence, the direction will reverse and the interest rates will come down. The current losses in the debt funds are due to the Mark to Market losses. That will turn to mark to market capital appreciation when the direction turns. That should be sooner than later. So, the fall in NAV seen now is purely temporary and will reverse and start giving profits in time. Hence, if as an investor, you stay invested, you may actually reap rich rewards in future.
Since, the medium & longterm debt funds, including Gilt funds have fallen now, the intrepid investor has a chance to get in now and ride the interest rate south side movement. This ofcourse has some risks as no one can predict exactly how the markets are going to unfold in future. RBI itself was not expecting the sharp yield spike in Gilts.

3.    Does one move from Equity to FD/ property/ Gold?  That seems like a logical thing to do. But the wrong thing to do!  Just because equity is doing badly now ( and has been doing so for the past five years ), you cannot write it off. You could, if you are going to write off India itself. Equity has performed in the past and it will in future too.

Moving from Equity to another asset class now will ensure that your loss or poor returns becomes real ( instead of notional ). Now if you invest in FDs, it could give stable returns, but it’s post tax returns cannot beat inflation. Moving it will look really silly once equity starts to move up. Equity movement can be meteoric after periods of languid meandering. Patience pays.
Property investments should be done on merits. Prices have gone up in the real estate markets quite sharply, for 7-8 years now. The upside can be modest. The probability of a downside or low returns on investments is a distinct possibility. Invest if you are convinced that you are getting a bargain.
Gold is dicey. The gold prices have gone up due to rupee depreciation & the import duties. In dollar terms it has actually gone down. If one were to look at the past year, Gold has moved from around $1,650 ( Sept 12 ) to an ounce to $1,370 now.

4.    That brings us to the concept of asset allocation. Investors need to decide what their goals are and to achieve their goals, what kind of asset mix is required. This has to be carefully chosen after due consideration for risk, return, tenure, liquidity, taxation etc. Stay invested based on that asset allocation. Every asset will not give good returns, at every point. But every asset has a role to play in the portfolio. We cannot expect to flit like a butterfly  from one asset to another and expect good portfolio returns. In fact retail investors are more known for entering at the end of a bull phase ( like say property ) and exiting in the middle of the bear phase ( like say equity ). Some tactical allocations can be done to take advantage of the prevailing situation; but this can be on just 5-15% of the portfolio.

5.    Opportunities – Fixed Maturity Plans ( FMP ) has the potential to offer between 9 -10% post tax returns, based on the yields of the underlying instruments for tenures between one to three years. For those who do not want interest rate risk, this is an excellent instrument. Those with a higher risk appetite should wait it out in debt funds.

Lots of equity funds have been beaten down.  The best way forward is to keep the SIPs on. The more daring approach is to invest in equity assets now. That ofcourse is not for everyone and is to be attempted only by those having a high risk appetite.

6.    Caution – Do not assume any liabilities at this point when the economy is in doldrums.  Keep the expenses down. Postpone any capital purchases. Don’t try anything fancy. Don’t keep seeing the prices of your investments daily. It can give you ulcers & hypertension. Just stick to your routines.


When you are in quick sand you go down faster if you move vigourosly. Bring forth your survival instincts. Things are currently bad. But in every situation, the results are based on how you react & take advantage of the situation. That alone separates the men from the boys. Go ahead, earn your stripes!

Author - Suresh Sadagopan    |    www.ladder7.co.in

Planning the investment mix for a Business owner

Think this over – It will be great if all flowers in the inflorescence turn to mangoes. But normally, there are just 3-4 mangoes per bunch, even though there are hundreds of flowers per bunch.

This has some interesting parallels for us as regards one’s investments. Everything you invest in would not give great results.  Atleast, it will all not do well at the same time, though we would very much like that to happen. There are going to be some at any point that are doing well. But that does not mean the other portions of the portfolio needs to be channeled into what is working today.

Investments cannot be done looking at the rear view mirror. It has to be rather done on what will work, going forward. But that is extremely difficult to predict, in the best of times. When there is a global churn, like now, it is almost impossible to predict which assets will do well, going forward.

Even within an asset class there are sub categories, which should not be disturbed. If one is investing in  equity through Mutual Funds, one cannot channel large cap investment into sectoral funds, just because they are doing well now. The risk-return profile for both, are different. Also, importantly, one does not know if sectoral funds will do as well, going forward.

But then a normal investor does just that. Moreover, they wait on the sidelines till the asset class has run up and participate at the end of the rally. So they never make money as they came in pretty late. The crux of what I’m driving at is that one should think well and come up with suitable asset allocation and stick to it. Tactical changes to the portfolio can be made though. But, one should not completely overturn a properly thought out strategy.


There is an important consideration while putting together a portfolio strategy for a business owner. Apart from various other considerations, a business owner is additionally exposed to higher risks emanating from the business itself. The income from the business itself is contingent on how well the business is doing. A business performance has several aspects which can all impact performance –  input & other costs, competitive pressures, obsolescence, market shifts, skilled manpower availability, regulatory business environment etc. As we can see, there are several factors which are not in control of an entrepreneur. These can result in further investments to continue the business, operations becoming expensive & profits coming down as a result. This can well result in lower income or can result in income fluctuations.


We need to factor this when drawing up a portfolio strategy for an entrepreneur. One factor that clearly emerges here is that the risk an entrepreneur is exposed to and by corollary his personal life, is high. Hence, the risks one can take in the portfolio should be lesser than in case of another, who is in service.

Most proprietors do not bifurcate the business income and their own drawals & spend everything from the same account. This should be avoided to bring in discipline, clarity & eliminate confusions in accounting. Lastly, business owners should have proper insurances in place – Life insurance & Key man insurance, health insurance for the family, professional indemnity where applicable, Premises insurance & other insurances as applicable.    

These are ofcourse the broad contours.  There are ofcourse going to variations as per individual situation. Stay hungry, stay foolish advice of Steve Jobs does not apply here! 

The other aspect to be addressed is the fluctuating income. We regularly suggest a liquidity margin of three months expenses. In case of a business owner, the margin should be much higher – ranging from six months to one year so that there are no hardships, if there is a prolonged phase of dip in income. If the business is such that, it may require cash infusions or capital investments from time to time, one needs to create that provision too and use it when needed.

Author : Suresh Sadagopan  | www.ladder7.co.in


The economy continues to look down cast with various indicators coming out looking decidedly bearish. The IIP numbers, Purchasing Managers Index, Inflation, GDP number etc., leave much to be desired. In the sea of misery, there is one redeeming ark – the trade deficit has narrowed sharply, which is possibly the only good news. Another one – the monsoon has been good and is expected to boost the rural incomes.

Stock markets have been buffeted by the falling rupee & the exit of money by FIIs. Equity markets have been affected & how! Among this, the mid and small cap stocks have seen massive erosions, some of them as high as 95%!!!

Consequently, mutual funds have also had their rough patch. They have fallen less due to diversification & fund manager actions, that inherently is one of the strong suits of MF schemes.

The sour point now is that even the debt markets have turned turbulent due to RBI actions, which have effectively increased the borrowing costs for the banks.  All this has put a question mark on what we need to do now. That is exactly what I’m writing for.

What do you do now ?

1.    Equity  - One of the frequently asked questions is whether the Equity SIP should be stopped.  The short answer is – No.
Equity SIPs are done with a longer investment horizon for meeting future goals. Also, the best way to invest in equity assets is through small monthly investments which does away with the need to time the markets & ensures cost averaging ( apart from various other pluses ). Hence, stopping the existing equity SIPs is not a sound idea.
As far as the existing equity investments are concerned it is better to stay put rather than change anything at this point. When the markets are in a tizzy, it pays to go by the dictum which stood our past PM ( Narasimha Rao, who was the first one to anoint it with ceremonial honours !) in good stead – No action is also action.
In due course, the markets will calm down, when the effect of the corrective action being taken, bears fruit.

2.    Debt  - After the shock treatment meted out by RBI, investors are skeptical about the debt markets too. But look at the other fact – RBI cannot keep the interest rates this high and will have to reverse it sooner than later, if it does not want to as the chief architect of a crippled economy.
Hence, the direction will reverse and the interest rates will come down. The current losses in the debt funds are due to the Mark to Market losses. That will turn to mark to market capital appreciation when the direction turns. That should be sooner than later. So, the fall in NAV seen now is purely temporary and will reverse and start giving profits in time. Hence, if as an investor, you stay invested, you may actually reap rich rewards in future.
Since, the medium & longterm debt funds, including Gilt funds have fallen now, the intrepid investor has a chance to get in now and ride the interest rate south side movement. This ofcourse has some risks as no one can predict exactly how the markets are going to unfold in future. RBI itself was not expecting the sharp yield spike in Gilts.

3.    Does one move from Equity to FD/ property/ Gold?  That seems like a logical thing to do. But the wrong thing to do!  Just because equity is doing badly now ( and has been doing so for the past five years ), you cannot write it off. You could, if you are going to write off India itself. Equity has performed in the past and it will in future too.
Moving from Equity to another asset class now will ensure that your loss or poor returns becomes real ( instead of notional ). Now if you invest in FDs, it could give stable returns, but it’s post tax returns cannot beat inflation. Moving it will look really silly once equity starts to move up. Equity movement can be meteoric after periods of languid meandering. Patience pays.
Property investments should be done on merits. Prices have gone up in the real estate markets quite sharply, for 7-8 years now. The upside can be modest. The probability of a downside or low returns on investments is a distinct possibility. Invest if you are convinced that you are getting a bargain.
Gold is dicey. The gold prices have gone up due to rupee depreciation & the import duties. In dollar terms it has actually gone down. If one were to look at the past year, Gold has moved from around $1,650 ( Sept 12 ) to an ounce to $1,370 now.
4.    That brings us to the concept of asset allocation. Investors need to decide what their goals are and to achieve their goals, what kind of asset mix is required. This has to be carefully chosen after due consideration for risk, return, tenure, liquidity, taxation etc. Stay invested based on that asset allocation. Every asset will not give good returns, at every point. But every asset has a role to play in the portfolio. We cannot expect to flit like a butterfly  from one asset to another and expect good portfolio returns. In fact retail investors are more known for entering at the end of a bull phase ( like say property ) and exiting in the middle of the bear phase ( like say equity ). Some tactical allocations can be done to take advantage of the prevailing situation; but this can be on just 5-15% of the portfolio.

5.    Opportunities – Fixed Maturity Plans ( FMP ) has the potential to offer between 9 -10% post tax returns, based on the yields of the underlying instruments for tenures between one to three years. For those who do not want interest rate risk, this is an excellent instrument. Those with a higher risk appetite should wait it out in debt funds.

Lots of equity funds have been beaten down.  The best way forward is to keep the SIPs on. The more daring approach is to invest in equity assets now. That ofcourse is not for everyone and is to be attempted only by those having a high risk appetite.

6.    Caution – Do not assume any liabilities at this point when the economy is in doldrums.  Keep the expenses down. Postpone any capital purchases. Don’t try anything fancy. Don’t keep seeing the prices of your investments daily. It can give you ulcers & hypertension. Just stick to your routines.

When you are in quick sand you go down faster if you move vigourosly. Bring forth your survival instincts. Things are currently bad. But in every situation, the results are based on how you react & take advantage of the situation. That alone separates the men from the boys. Go ahead, earn your stripes!

Author – Suresh Sadagopan | Founder | Ladder7 Financial Advisories | www.ladder7.co.in

26 June, 2013

Interview in CafeMutual

This is my interview regarding The Financial Planners' Guild, India, of which I'm the president.

http://www.cafemutual.com/News/FPG-is-an-exclusive-club-of-financial-planners-Suresh-Sadagopan~157~Cli~FinancialPlanning~61

Interview in Wealthforum...


The following is an interview I had given to Wealthforum. It is my story infact!


http://wealthforumezine.net/Advisorspeak040613.html#.Ucrs2jsdvE1

Should you invest abroad?

India, it is believed, is an economy which has phenomenal potential and one of the major economies which can grow over 5%, in real terms for decades. We had all believed that Indian economy has structurally shifted to a much higher plane, in terms of GDP growth at 8.5-9%, a few years back. Some of the worthies even started talking about double digit growth. In hindsight, it had just been wishful thinking, without substance for we never put in place the infrastructure or the enabling environment for such high growth to take root.


The dream lies in tatters. All in the BRIC grouping are in doldrums, with only China in a reasonably good shape.  We thought that since we are a developing economy ( by many indicators we are actually under developed ) and since the population is young, there will be lots of growth here. By corollary, we expected the “developing” economies like ours to offer much higher returns on our investment, due to the explosive growth rate.


Again, this remains on paper. When the global meltdown happened, our market, along with other emerging economies tumbled much more than the US markets! This happened, inspite of the fact that it was the epicentre of the crisis itself!


Now, what about the returns since… The annualised returns that Sensex has offered is a 5% & 4.5% for three and five year periods. Nasdaq has given returns of 16.8% & 7% respectively, for the same time periods. It is instructive to look at the performance of various markets. Emerging markets as a group have done worse than the US & UK markets, in terms of annualised returns.  Malaysia was an exception. Please refer to the table.


Name
Type
As of Date
1-Year
3-Year
5-Year

Morningstar Stock Indexes
Broad Market





US Market
TR
41461
28.25
18.87
6.5






Name
Type
As of Date
1-Year
3-Year
5-Year






Other Domestic Stock Indexes
DJ Industrial Average TR
TR
41461
25.69
18.97
7.54
NASDAQ Composite PR
PR
41461
22.54
16.86
6.99
NYSE Composite PR
---
41461
24.41
12.83
0.44
Russell 2000 TR
TR
41461
31.79
18.49
7.46
S&P 500 TR
TR
41461
27.82
18.61
6.19
S&P MidCap 400
TR
41461
30.66
19.61
7.88
Foreign Indexes
DJ Malaysia PR USD
TR
41461
17.49
15.49
8.49
Euronext BEL 20 PR EUR
PR
41461
24.64
2.84
-6.51
Euronext Paris CAC 40 NR EUR
TR
41461
29.81
7.45
-0.99
Euronext Paris CAC 40 PR EUR
PR
41461
26.1
4.29
-4.18
FSE DAX PR EUR
PR
41461
29.94
8.01
0.3
FSE DAX TR EUR
TR
41461
34.35
11.81
3.94
FTSE 100 TR GBP
TR
41461
21.93
11.99
5.52
FTSE 250 PR GBP
PR
41461
30.34
13.9
7.33
Hang Seng Hong Kong Composite PR HKD
TR
41553
17.56
3.15
-2
Hang Seng HSI PR HKD
PR
41553
17.11
3.34
-1.51
Nikkei 225 Average PR JPY
PR
41553
59.76
12.3
-0.73
S&P BSE SENSEX India INR
PR
41461
16.7
5.01
4.53
S&P/TSX Composite PR
PR
41461
6.74
2.46
-3.74
Shanghai SE Composite PR CNY
PR
41461
-3.59
-4.16
-7.86












































 What should Indian investors do?


When we invest, we will definitely have a home country bias.  This is a universal phenomenon. However, we have clear proof that inspite of poor GDP numbers, the US & UK stock markets have given far better returns than most emerging markets. It will indeed be prudent to invest a portion of one’s assets in such markets.  While we can debate the quantum of investments in markets abroad, upto a 20% allocation seems fair.


How to invest?


Participating in these markets is best done through mutual funds, as a normal investor or even their advisor may know nothing about those markets or the companies there. Now, choosing correct schemes to invest is also a massive exercise in itself as there are thousands of schemes out there. Also, the entry load in most of these schemes is high at 4%or more, for retail investors.


The workaround is to participate in Indian MF schemes, investing abroad. Again, even here, those managing the investments from India would either have access to research from abroad or have a feeder fund which invests in a fund abroad. A feeder fund is preferred as the main fund ( which receives the investment ) would be an existing performing fund, managed by fund managers sitting in those markets and managing the investments. Also, since these Indian schemes collect and invest as an institution, the entry/ marketing charges are normally not there. This benefits the Indian investor, though he may pay another 0.5-0.75% more for a feeder fund, as compared to a normal indian equity MF scheme.


What kind of funds could one invest in?


The funds that invest into broad index or are diversified would be the ones to look out for. Since markets abroad are far more efficient, index funds may be a better bet as outperformance could be very difficult for managed funds. Apart from index funds, once can look for specific funds that invest in different themes like real assets ( as opposed to financial or IP assets ) like L&T Global real assets fund, real estate like ING Global Real Estate Fund, Index oriented like MOST Nasdaq 100 etc.  One can look at broad emerging market funds too, which invest across the globe.


There is one more major advantage to investing in these global funds. Companies which form a part of these global funds have global foot print and hence anyway participate in the growth happening worldwide. That way, though these are US or UK head quartered companies, they are truly global.   


There is a word of caution. The investments are subject to currency movements and that can affect returns. Need to keep that in mind while investing.



We need to change & emerge out of our reverie. There  are other markets which are performing better and we should have an open mind to diversify our investments there.  No point in adopting an ostrich approach, thinking Indian markets can beat all other markets. We know better now!

Published in Business standard on 12/6/2013; Author - Suresh Sadagopan ; www.ladder7.co.in